4th October, 1923
| First Name | Surname | Suburb | State | Points | Placing |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Negative - R.B. | McLeay | Adelaide | South Australia | 145.00 | 1st |
| Negative - S. | Dunks | Adelaide | South Australia | 140.00 | 2nd |
| Affirmative - Roy | Eva | Ballarat | Victoria | 137.00 | 3rd |
| Affirmative - W.J. | McCaskill | Footscray | Victoria | 130.00 | Honourable Mention |
